The new season of Premier League Fantasy Football is live, and the player prices are officially set. It's time for fans to start assembling their squads, and for Everton supporters, that comes with a few unique dilemmas.
With a limited budget and fierce competition across every position, selecting the best three Everton players could be the key to maximizing value while keeping club loyalty intact. Whether you're planning to go all-in on top performers from across the league or trying to squeeze a few Toffees into your starting XI, careful strategy is essential.
In this breakdown, we explore the key FPL categories that will determine whether your team is built for glory, or heading for another frustrating campaign. Will you rise up the ranks or suffer the same old mid-table fate? Let the planning begin.
Consistent top performers
Clean sheets were the foundation of Everton’s success last season, with goalkeepers and defenders leading the way in Fantasy Premier League points. Jordan Pickford topped the squad with an impressive 158 points, and as the undisputed first-choice goalkeeper, he’s a solid bet for another 100+ point season, especially at a reasonable price of £5.5 million.
Defenders Vitalii Mykolenko and James Tarkowski also proved reliable assets, each surpassing the 100-point mark. Priced at £5.0 million and £5.5 million respectively, they offer strong value, particularly if David Moyes can build on the team’s improved form from the latter half of last season.
With a favourable start to the campaign, facing Leeds United, Brighton, and Wolves in the opening three fixtures, Everton’s back line presents an early opportunity for FPL managers to rack up clean sheet points.
Despite it being his first season, Iliman Ndiaye emerged as Everton’s top-performing attacker, racking up an impressive 114 FPL points. Priced at £6.5 million, the Senegalese midfielder offers strong value, especially given his attacking threat and goal-scoring potential. For Everton fans and FPL managers alike, he’s a compelling option to consider.
New signings
Everton have bolstered their squad with two new signings: French striker Thierno Barry and goalkeeper Mark Travers.
Barry, in particular, is an intriguing prospect. With the number nine role still very much up for grabs, the young forward could be a game-changer for your team. Priced at just £6 million in FPL, he represents a budget-friendly option with the potential for real impact. If he settles quickly, Barry could be the striker to breathe new life into Everton’s attack.
Mark Travers' £4.5 million price tag in FPL is largely irrelevant—unless Jordan Pickford suffers an injury. The Irish goalkeeper is expected to serve primarily as a backup to the England international and is unlikely to accumulate many points this season.
Meanwhile, Charly Alcaraz can also be seen as a fresh addition to the squad after making his loan move permanent this summer. Priced at £5.5 million in FPL, the Argentine could offer strong value if he builds on last season and takes a step forward in his development.
Cheapest efficiency
With several departures and more signings expected, predicting Everton’s starting XI remains a challenge.
Key questions linger around the right-back position, the central midfield setup, whether it’s a duo or trio, and who will lead the line up front. The first few fixtures of the season should provide a clearer picture of David Moyes’ preferred lineup.
In attack, the duo of Dwight McNeil (£6.0 million) and Beto (£5.5 million) offers promising value. Both have the potential to deliver points through goals and assists, with McNeil also benefiting from clean sheet bonuses due to his midfield classification.
Elsewhere, budget-friendly defenders like Jarrad Branthwaite (£5.5 million), Jake O’Brien (£5.0 million), and Harrison Armstrong (£4.5 million) could be worth monitoring as potential enablers, especially if they lock down regular starting roles early in the season.